Laura Lao · · 5 min read
How I would hire PMs now
I wouldn't use the same process I used last year if I were hiring a PM now.
Why? Well, because:
The most desirable qualities in PMs have changed.
Traditional processes with dated artefacts are ineffective.
Let’s travel back to last year
The process I used was fairly standard in the industry. It started with CVs and short application questions, followed by a 30-minute introductory call, before candidates were put through a take-home task, which they then presented and answered questions about in a one-hour session. After that, they were invited for an on-site visit, where a whiteboarding exercise and a cultural interview took place. The assessment concluded with a final 30-minute call with the CEO.
The most desirable qualities in PMs have changed
PMs are mini CEOs. They discover opportunities, set priorities and develop solutions, and deliver business value through this process.
Before AI, each part took longer and required more resources and expertise. PMs orchestrated people, time and money to achieve their goals. This was a highly complex undertaking, so the product management discipline developed many processes and frameworks to help. PMs’ seniority was often judged on their knowledge of these frameworks and their experience using them. That made them an important part of the hiring assessment.
But AI changes the game.
It can help PMs gain knowledge, gather information, analyse data, devise solutions and even build the product, all at an incredible speed. An idea can pop up in the morning and be released for testing in the afternoon. This means the cost of failure has fallen dramatically. The old processes and frameworks designed to minimise risk and avoid errors in judgement no longer carry the same weight.
Instead, agency, adaptability, values, first-principles thinking and resilience have become much more sought-after qualities in PMs.
Traditional processes with dated artefacts are ineffective
Looking back at the process I ran last year, I’m genuinely shocked by how much effort we invested and how inefficient it all was.
We received 500 CVs, each reviewed by two people for about a minute each. That’s 17 hours combined.
10% of CVs made it to the introductory call. That’s 25 hours.
40% of them were then given the take-home task. That’s 40 hours.
50% of them were then invited to the on-site visit. That’s 60 hours.
5 made it to the final call. That’s 3 hours.
Interview prep is roughly estimated to take 10% of the interview time. That’s 13 hours.
This comes to a total of 158 hours, which is roughly a person’s entire month of work. Of course, the reality was, hiring someone for this role took much more time and effort once we factored in post-interview debriefs, scorecard writing, context switching, interview scheduling and communication with candidates.
Looking back, I think we needed the long hiring process to compensate for the weak signals at each stage.
We could only get a hint of the candidate from the CV, so we had an introductory call. We couldn’t really see the candidate’s capability in the call, so we gave them the take-home task. We couldn’t observe how the candidate thinks on their feet, so we had the whiteboarding exercise.
What saddens me even more is that ours was just the norm. There are many companies out there that have even longer processes and more hoops for the candidates to jump through, sometimes for roles that are much less senior than the one we hired for.
What I would do today
Instead of assessing knowledge and experience, I will place much greater importance on agency, adaptability, ingenuity, first-principles thinking and integrity. I assume candidates will use AI for their applications. In fact, using AI effectively will be an important part of the assessment.
I won’t bother with CVs. As my cofounder Mario has said in his article, CVs are dead. They don’t tell us much about the candidates, and they introduce a tonne of unconscious bias in the process.
Instead, I will ask the candidates to tell us their stories and how they handle different situations. That will help us get to know their values, personal qualities and ambitions. I will do this through an application form bespoke to the role I’m hiring for, in the same way that VC incubators select their portfolio companies. Candidates will no doubt use AI to complete this, but those who use it without thinking for themselves will be easy to spot because their answers will lack substance.
I will also remove the take-home task. Instead, the candidate will solve a problem with access to a range of AI tools. I will use that as an opportunity to observe their approach, their ability to reason, their collaboration style, their creativity in finding solutions, and how they react when their point of view is challenged. I reckon I will get a very strong read on the candidate during those 60 to 90 minutes.
I will reduce the number of steps in my hiring process. To do that while maintaining or even improving hiring quality, I will get everyone on the hiring team aligned on what we are looking for in candidates. Every assessment must be supported by objective evidence. Scorecards with subjective opinions, submitted late under the influence of others, will not be considered in decision-making.
AI has brought a seismic shift to hiring
We can no longer continue with the old ways and expect to get good results. This presents us with a great opportunity to rethink hiring from the ground up. I’m thrilled to be building Wolven at this exciting time, offering a completely different approach for teams that are yearning for something new, something that works. If that sounds like your team, get in touch.